Are actual authentic jerseys too much to ask for?

The executives with Reebok and Nike certainly know what they’re doing. The same can be said for those who control apparel pricing in the NFL and NHL.

Go into any team store, Dicks or anywhere else that team apparel is sold and you will likely need to extend your student loans just to purchase a jersey. That is if you’re a jersey kind of guy. Personally, I’ve never gotten down with wearing jerseys to a game. I feel awkward when I’m in it and there is also the impending threat of a trade or free agency sending your player out of town. Blank jerseys are obviously safer, but not nearly as meaningful as one that looks like the duds worn on the field or rink.

Not technically authentic.
An NHL fan is going to spend roughly $150 for a replica uniform and well north of $300 for an authentic sweater from the NHL. Football fans have a similar financial burden. There are three options that range in terms of quality and price from $100, $135 and $300 each.

Perhaps the biggest drawback for buying an NFL jersey is that fact that your cheapest option is little more than a $100 mesh t-shirt with screen printed numbers. The secondary product is closer in form to what is seen on the field and the authentic jerseys have all the bells and whistles as the on-field product (to a certain extent).

The issue here is the way the NFL jerseys are constructed for retail. The lowest replica, as previously stated, isn’t even close to being worth the investment. However, the authentic jersey is equivalent in price to an average television and that jersey shouldn’t even qualify as authentic.

One of the things the NHL has gotten right is that the replica jersey you can purchase for $150 bears many similarities to the jersey worn on the ice. There are obvious differences, but you still get sewn on numbers and the cut and fit is that of what a hockey player (bender or NHLer) would wear. The authentic could probably be taken off the rack and put on a player for a game if necessary. From the fight strap to the stretch paneling, Reebok EDGE uniforms are the same as you see on the ice each night.

NFL uniforms don’t mimic this. Now, football jerseys have become increasingly tight and have slowly lost their sleeves over the last decade or so. The hope to avoid holding and extra fabric to grab at has made football uniforms shrink into a variation of a belly shirt.

These changes have not been reflected on the retail versions, no matter if you’re buying price point or authentic. The $300 versions come with the mesh paneling, stitched numbers and flywire collars, but nothing else. The question fans need to ask is: why bother paying $300 for a jersey that isn’t even close to what you see Mario Williams wear each week?

Now, there is no need to have capped sleeves and skin-tight tailoring. But if fans are paying $300, they should at least have features that make the uniforms look closer to what is worn on the field. Simply shortening the sleeves and adding elastic would make the jerseys look more similar to their on-field cousins while also eliminating the ridiculous sleeves the retail models have.

At the end of the day, people will continue to buy jerseys regardless of how they look. It just seems unfortunate that the country’s biggest sports league can’t give their fans a product closer to the one worn by the players motivating their purchase.


6 thoughts on “Are actual authentic jerseys too much to ask for?

  1. klejdys September 10, 2012 / 12:14 pm

    Those companies (reebok, nike) have to make jerseys that fit over large pads, so you’d end up looking puffy if you went with the complete “game worn” package. I believe the NFL is okay going with an “authentic” jersey (sewn on layered lettering, etc.) over an “on-field” version, which is meant for professional athletes wearing pads, rather than for Joe-6 pack.

    Check out this auction for Bills game worn, for example:

    The jerseys are all tailored. Most fans don’t need that level of detail or tailoring. I have a Nate Clements old-style blue game worn; forget about wearing it. It’s a 44 chest with +2L and for most fans, it’d be the equivalent of stuffing meat into sausage casing.

    The irony in hockey is that the new jerseys are more tailored than the old CCM airknits (which I loved). A 50 in the new Reeboks is almost unwearable for me (46 chest) because the new unis were designed to reduce drag and increase moisture wicking. Many fans prefer their jerseys baggy, so they can wear layers underneath, especially if/when the weather gets cold.


    • Chris Ostrander September 10, 2012 / 1:30 pm

      Maybe I didn’t go into enough detail about the NFL ones. I think the in store authentic jerseys need to be closer to what is worn on field…the on fields dont even have sleeves most of the time. But I’d rather have something slightly similar in terms of the cut and, more importantly, the goofy sleeves the retail models have.

      The NHL authentication are dead on in the cut and fit just because of the way they’re made and worn – no alterations like the NFL. Although the stretch paneling on both makes it tough for regular guys to wear a tighter fit.


  2. stan July 14, 2016 / 2:39 pm

    Any movement on this? I just asked Under Armour if they will come out with a “on field” type jersey as I agree, the jerseys, sleeves in particular are not “on field.”


    • Chris Ostrander July 14, 2016 / 3:17 pm

      Nothing that I’ve heard of in terms of the various things I read. I’m honestly surprised football jerseys don’t have at least one option that is closer to an on-field replica than an oddly sized t-shirt with heat pressed lettering and mesh panels.


  3. jesse August 30, 2016 / 2:57 am

    I agree with you buddy 110%. I used to have a college jersey with the capped sleeves and it fit great!! these other ones with long ass sleeves are just way too gigantic.


  4. Anthony Misso May 14, 2017 / 2:50 pm

    I totally agree if I could find more realistic NFL jerseys like they wear on Sunday I would pay 500 for it. I collect real jerseys

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s